When we talk about the financial crisis in Puerto Rico, we should analyze the roles the Puerto Rican and United States governments played in the situation. We shouldn’t, however, write an insensitive and racist ditty that makes light of what’s happening on the island. Yet on Friday, a group of financial journalists dressed up in zarapes and sombreros (eye roll) and did just that. At the New York Financial Writers Association’s Financial Follies fundraiser on Friday, “a bunch of white people” mocked the financial situation in Puerto Rico.
So, #financialfollies just did a disgustingly racist skit about #PuertoRico ‘s Bankrutpcy, in which a bunch of white people danced around in sombreros and ponchos, pretending to be Puerto Rican. Because apparently all Latinos are the same.
— Nick Brown (@NickPBrown) November 10, 2018
So #financialfollies put on a song and dance routine with people dressed in Mexican garb making light of Puerto Rico's debt crisis. I don't know where to begin here. pic.twitter.com/XfbjczwCgu
— Alex Wolf (@awolf86) November 10, 2018
Reuters journalist Nick Brown documented the moment on Twitter, where he criticized everything from what they wore to the insensitive lyrics of their song. To the tune of “Despacito,” the group sang, “We can help you with your little bankruptcito / we’re the brains, you’re the debtor in ‘el possessionito’ / words tun into Spanish just by adding ‘ito’ / when we’re in San juan we drink mojito-itos / & look out for the Zika from the ‘squitos.”
Lyrics (tune of Despacito): we can help you with your little bankruptcito/we’re the brains, you’re the debtor in ‘el possessionito’/words turn into Spanish just by adding ‘ito’/when we’re in San Juan we drink mojito-itos/& look out 4 the Zika from the ‘squitos #FinancialFollies https://t.co/717jfKeHnR
— Nick Brown (@NickPBrown) November 10, 2018
#financialfollies is a journalism industry event in New York every year to poke fun at financial journalists and the stories we cover. But sometimes the skits are tone deaf and betray a lack of understanding. IMO, this was one such moment. https://t.co/HQOeFJ8k4n
— Nick Brown (@NickPBrown) November 12, 2018
On top of being dehumanizing, this skit is an issue because the field of journalism continues being incredibly white. If these are the people who are documenting, analyzing, and writing about Puerto Rico, then how can they be trusted to deliver news that isn’t shaded by their own biases?
Update, November 12, 2018 at 5 p.m. ET: After backlash, the New York Financial Writers’ Association released a statement: “Some attendees of our Nov. 9 event took offense at certain parody songs that accompany the annual Financial Follies dinner. The NYFWA board wishes to make clear that was not our intention and we apologize for any offense taken. The NYFWA understands and supports the art and spirit of parody and satire which is, and has been, the 76-year tradition of the Financial Follies… It is an art form of nuanced messaging that must be taken in its full context, as must all forms of parody and satire. This year, that messaging included actors portraying sexist men in our “Me Too” era, and ignorant bankers who fueled Puerto Rico’s debt crisis. Those were the intended targets of the skits. We regret any possible confusion that some in the audience might have drawn from the messaging; its intention was clearly to mock the perpetrators, not deride the victims.”